Sunday, February 24, 2013

Kokoro: Judo




Class Date:

2.21.13 & 2.23.13

Website:
http://www.kokorojudoatx.com
Facebook page (Closed group, requires membership)
Youtube

Instructor:
Complicated. (Led by about 7 black belts, it seems)

Lineage:
N/A? Various.

Credentials:
Non-profit. Good Yelp reviews. "Officially sanctioned club by USA Judo, with a certified coaching staff."

Number:
N/A.

Email:
glenn dot macias at gmail dot com
(Private email of one of the instructors)

Location:
Right on Oltorf & South 5th--The Salvation Army building.

Enter in the door on the furthest right side of the building. You'll see the Chess club. Continue into the back of the room, past the bathrooms, and into a closed door at the end. That's the gym entrance; class is held in there. (The Chess club people will help you if you ask. They're friendly. :)


1001 Cumberland Dr.


View Larger Map

Free:

All and None. Read below.

Price:
2 classes /week @ $20/month*

Classes are 1.5-2 hours each.

*This Dojo is non-profit. The fee represents the costs of keeping the place running. That being said, supposedly, if money is tight, you can go a month or two without paying. I wouldn't do that until you get established as a member of the group, mind you, and given how cheap it is, even I feel inclined to pay the fee--and I made less than 50% of the poverty level last year. On the other hand, if you feel like supporting what they do, you're welcome to give more.

Short review:

Great little non-profit. No major complaints. Class diversity of skill is good, plenty of upper level instruction, moderately intense vibe. Lots of calisthenics keep you on your toes, interspersed throughout the class. Definitely worth your time.

============================================================

Preamble:

So, to be clear, this is a Judo class, not a Jiu Jitsu class. That being said, BJJ comes directly from Judo, and can be considered an expansion of Judo's Newaza (groundwork) portion. The other thing to note is that many (most, it seems?) of the practitioners here cross-train in BJJ. The teacher who led my first class at Kokoro actually has a brown belt in BJJ and teaches a Judo class at Paragon, a BJJ gym on my list. At least one other student trains at Paragon, and another trains at Relson. I've also seen a "Gracie" gi there.

I've always wanted to cross train in Judo. In my first classes of BJJ, I knew a particular guy I rolled with who had some training in Judo, and I was always trying to get him to teach me something. (It never really jived, unfortunately.)

In Israel, the dojo I studied at cross trained extensively in BJJ and Judo, and sparring was basically anything goes. That was my first exposure to Judo. I remember the first time I ever pulled off a Judo throw, after a class on some throws that day--I was totally elated.

So, when I was looking for BJJ locations in Austin, and one list I was going through mentioned some Judo places, I went ahead and added them to the list.

I only have two Judo locations on my list to visit, one of which is Kokoro. But even the other place on the list, Team Haas Judo, has as their most expensive option a price equal to only the very cheapest BJJ. I think this shows pretty clearly the somewhat absurd inflation of BJJ prices... Paying 15-20 an hour for group rate training isn't very reasonable. Judo prices don't reflect the UFC hype driving up BJJ prices.

I digress. Judo is cheap(er than BJJ); but kokoro is a non-profit, and I love non-profits. And not just because they're cheap--I learned Salsa dancing at a large free group that was student run at my University. The quality of teaching was far above anything I've been able to find since (alas), the atmosphere was superior, and we had plenty of time to practice after every class as we all threw a big party together. When money isn't an issue, some great things start to happen--some things that money just can't buy.

Actual Review:

Some of the instructors standing in the chess room up front
So what's the place like? The facility is an old indoor basketball gym with lofty ceilings. Three banners along the left side indicate to the reader that the 'dojo' is and has been an official club of USA Judo since 2010. The mats look fairly high quality, not the cheap puzzleboard stuff seen at some places. While they looked clean, I never actually saw them cleaned during either class (though I did hear it discussed once). Some seem to stay out at all times, and depending on class size, we pull out more to accommodate.



The class feels pretty old school martial arts. Everyone bows as they get on the mat, and the class bows towards the instructors at the beginning. You start out with about 30 minutes of working out. The Thursday class I went to was a killer--I was frustrated, it was so much working out. The Saturday class following wasn't quite so intense a workout, but it was still significant. Workouts included a quick-paced jog around the mats, pushups of various types, "Burpees", leg lifts, sit ups, lunges, and so forth. All at a pace that keeps your cardio up.

Normally this bothers me. And during the moment, I was definitely bothered. But Judo, moreso than BJJ, requires strength to execute, so it makes more sense for them to include it as a regimented part of their study. By the second class, I was grateful--I don't push myself as hard when I train alone, so it makes for a nice baseline workout on top of the meager 20 pullups/20 floating leg lifts/20 dips I do as my current daily baseline workout.

Next is drills. We did some rolling/landing drills, and some technique drills. The technique drill changed between the classes, which seems like a good idea.

Then Technique study. We had three techniques we practiced, and split up into pairs to practice on each other, one by one. Instruction was sufficiently clear, and the instructors went around giving helpful tips and further instruction as the practice went on. This is a special advantage of the multi-instructor format: plenty of teachers to give attention as the time went on.

Lastly, Randori. The first class I was only allowed to Randori for one round (would have been two, but the numbers were off or something as far as class size). That's fairly standard for a new guy. By the second class, though, I was fully integrated, and allowed to participate in Randori freely.

Between every 3 minute Randori round, everyone does some quick workout--20 pushups, or 20 toe touches with legs perpendicular to the ground, for example--and then you change partners.

After that, there were a few more workouts and stretches.

Class ended with the students lined up bowing to the teachers who were facing them from across the room.

The class skill distribution was, as I had read in advance, pretty well distributed. There were 3 black belts and 2 brown belts during the two classes I went to. There were yellows and greens present at both classes I went to. And there were a few whites of different abilities at both classes as well.

The tone was not overly aggressive, but it was definitely tipped just a bit towards the aggressive side of the scale while still being fairly respectful; ultimately, I feel like the instructors maintain a fairly moderate intensity that shows a lot of control and reservation, while the competitiveness of the individual students varied person to person. The class is definitely geared towards progress and has a serious tone to it, however, and could not be said to be 'laid back'.

The teachers were pretty respectful, and relatable. While on the mat, they were given their due respect (I haven't heard anyone say 'sensei' yet, mind you), but off the mat, they are just another friend there to help you, who you want to respect simply because he's giving away instruction just for the sake of building karma.

One of the teachers offered to help me carpool when he heard how far away it was for me.

While I will keep looking for a BJJ place, I plan on sticking around here. I definitely give this place the thumbs up.

(And yes, I'm still sore.)

Check out another review here from back when the group just started. This is where I heard about it.

--

A video of one of the instructors kicking ass in a competition:



Pros:
Stupid cheap
Sport/Kodokan Judo
Not limited to one particular teacher's influence
Good student skill ratios
Non-profit
Good mats
Good workout
Fun Randori
Lots of fellow BJJ students around

Cons:
Sport/competition focused, not lifestyle or 'traditional' (read: no longer allowed) techniques
Unglamorous facility
Lots of working out
No free rolling after class
No particularly high-ranked teachers, as far as I can tell (no "star power")
Only two classes a week

Sunday, February 17, 2013

Zen Jiu Jitsu: East Side Austin meets BJJ

Date:
Mid December '12

Website:
http://www.austinzenbjj.com/

Instructor:
Paul

Lineage:
Rigan Machado

Credentials:
Brown belt under Rigan Machado.

Number:
512.517.1509

Location:
2200 E 7th St.

View Larger Map

Free:
One class

Price:
2   classes /week @ $80/month
7* classes /week @ $100/month

Classes are 1-2 hours each.

*There are 7 BJJ classes per week, and other fitness classes.
*Given that this place is relatively new, expect them to experiment with pricing plans and options. It seems that they've already added more classes to their schedule as of March of 2013.


Short review:
Friendly, East Austin feel. Maybe a bit too friendly, if that's possible, but it's hard to fault the instructor for kindness. A "Fitness" focus seems a bit odd for a BJJ gym, but makes sense at Zen, where the vibe is definitely one of, well, "Zen" "Wellness" "Fitness"... A very Austin spin on BJJ, perhaps. New gym and community fresh out of the garage, so students are closer to the beginner end of the spectrum. Cheapest gym in Austin. Small classes. Tight knit community.


============================================================
*I should mention, to be fair, that I am writing this review about two months after attending. Perhaps, at the end of this experiment, I'll go back and give an updated review. For now, this will have to do.

I walked into Zen Jiu Jitsu based purely on a flyer alone. (Huh, waddya know, they do work...) I was hanging out at Epoch Coffee,



and saw this green and white Japanese looking sun. Zen Jiu Jitsu.



Hey, I was looking for some BJJ. I saw times and a phone number. I called. Guy sounded nice enough. Sure, why not give it a shot?

I grabbed the ol' kickskin, the same one I got when I was 16, pants thin and already sporting a tear, and headed out one Saturday morning. I had a little trouble finding the place while looking straight at it, though its location is pretty straightforward--just no sign of any kind, and it still looked like it hadn't opened from the outside.

Once inside, though, Zen's place is pretty spacious, wide open. Windows line the front. There was some workout equipment on the side wall, a small stereo putting out some quiet dubstep from the instructor's ipod. The instructor was an incredibly welcoming and kind guy. I felt like his cheeks should get sore from grinning so often, honestly, though it didn't feel insincere--he's just a happy guy. Exactly the kind of guy who would name his place 'Zen Jiu Jitsu'.

We worked out a bit at the beginning, mostly some drills (which I generally am not fond of, but I didn't mind this particular morning). If I remember correctly, we did technique first, following the shrimping and rolling drills.

The instructor had just opened the gym shortly before, thus the flyers. His students followed him here from his garage, so to speak. The newness of the school showed; there was one blue belt and a few white belts with stripes. One got the feeling that people were still getting used to the new place. The instructor being a brown belt lent further to the feeling that this was a student teaching other students (albeit obviously a qualified one--a Rigan Machado brown belt is nothing to shake a stick at).

The teaching, as I remember it, was on the easier side of interesting. The rolling was all pleasant enough. I found myself tapping everyone in the room (aside from the instructor) with some effort, which, while it felt great to 'win', leaves me with a lingering feeling of doubt about growth potential there for myself. (I wouldn't be being fair if I didn't admit that I was rusty enough that I was winded at the end, in spite of the victory.) The feel was definitely very 'Zen', though.

Rolling continued past the 1.5 hour limit freely. One thing definitely in this gym's favor is that they have exclusive lease of the gym--they can do what they want. This isn't a timeslot-rented space, no one else is coming after you, so do what you like. Definitely contributed to the laid back atmosphere.

The teacher was capable and gave good instruction. The attitude was chill. Not to say people were going less than 80% when we rolled, but... A vibe you'd expect from friends rolling together on the side. And when I left, I felt good about the whole experience.

I remember prices being $80/month total--I'm not sure if memory deceives me, and it was always $100 for unlimited, or if he actually raised his prices. Even still, he's the best deal in town for someone on a budget, and so it's not unlikely that I'll show up again at some point in the future to give an updated review.

In December, he was saying that if I paid then, he'd go ahead and thrown in all of January with the rest of December, a promotional to try and get more students in. Seems he was doing the same buy-1-get-1-free for Jan/Feb as well.

If I was just starting out right now, I'd seriously consider this gym a bit more than I do at the moment; it would be pretty cool to grow with an instructor from the beginning, maybe someday be his first black belt student. I kind of still would like to find some group doing BJJ in their garage, but those people don't have websites. In the end, though, I am left with a feeling that I wouldn't have anyone at my level to roll with.

Oh, by the way. My old pants? The one rip I had turned into three, and they were officially retired from service. I paused my quest for BJJ while I looked for some money and waited until I could afford some pants--but that's a story for another day.

Anyways, goes without saying that this place is subject to change. Take this review as a snapshot of their roots if you're reading this a few months after the fact.

Pros:
Open, spacious gym.
Generous classes.
Fitness options, if you're into that.
Friendly.
Rigan Machado-trained instructor.
Clean, open, though pleasantly unpolished.
Growing.
Cheapest in town.

Cons:
Brown, not black belt instructor.
Students are lower ranked, bad high-to-low student ranking ratio.
Maybe a bit too laid back for some tastes.
Not very established.

Austin Jiu Jitsu


Class Date:

2.14.13

Website:
www.austinjiujitsu.com
blogger.jitshappens.com
bjjtech.com

Instructor:
David Thomas

Lineage:
Travis Tooke, himself a student of Carlos Gracie Jr.
(? Began studies under William Vandry, a student of Carlos Machado)

Credentials:
Training BJJ since 1995. Martial arts since 1985. 2 Karate black belts to go along with his BJJ black belt. International competition experience. Experience in other various martial arts. Varied martial arts teaching background.

Number:
"(512) TAP-ROLL (827-7655)" (Well isn't that nifty?)

Location:
Right off Lamar & 24th
(Be sure to check out directions on his website, they're needed.)

View Larger Map

Free:

One class

Price:
1.5 classes /week @ $109-$119/month*
2 classes /week @ $123-$133/month*

Classes are 1.5-2 hours each.

*Pricing structure highly encourages buying classes in bulk, in advance, essentially contract commitments of three to six months. Single-monthly prices are not listed because they are discouraged, and will be higher.


Short review:
Great teacher, good vibes. Classroom is a little small, but not bothersome. Clean, professional. Friendly. Technical. Great location. If I didn't have a mission to complete, I would be tempted to stop here and make this my home dojo. A little pricey, but not bad; just keep in mind that you are paying lump sums in advance here.

============================================================


Why did I start with Austin Jiu Jitsu? There's a few reasons.

First off, he's the only one who had the courage to list his prices online--and while not quite the most expensive gig in town, he's certainly not the cheapest.

Calling him reinforced the impression of honesty that left on me. It was a breath of fresh air after the jaded feeling I was left with searching for BJJ online; the idea of not showing your prices until after you come in for a class feels like a dirty sales tactic, frankly, and I was glad to see someone who wasn't subject to that.

And I have to say, if it weren't for that, he wouldn't have been at the top of my list. He seemed good, but not a standout from my brief overview. And giving his website a second look, I think that may have been my error. Sure, he doesn't look like THE highest ranked guy in town, and yes, he was taught by other local teachers... But now that I go and read his reviews, and look at his videos... I should have put him fairly high on the list anyways. His youtube channel has 2600 subscribers, and well over three million video views--this guy makes some money off of youtube as a minor BJJ celebrity, in other words. He has this site as well, to make it easier to keep things organized: As I said, it was a jading process, going through all these websites.

I should mention that in the end, though, it was that he really invited me to come down tomorrow night and try it out. Sure, lots of people invited me to come--but it usually felt pushy. (Paragon was a bit of an exception.) With Dave, I just... I had a good vibe. It was a friend's invitation, not a saleman's.

So I grabbed the ol' gi and headed out. Traffic was bad, and I got a little lost, so I was 7 minutes late. Dave received me graciously anyways, showed me where I could change, and met me on the mat.

Dave's place is on the smaller side of medium, but it is comfortable, clean, and in an incredible location with regards to downtown. No funny smells, no dim lighting, no obnoxious loud music. Classes here start out with 45 minutes of rolling (free sparring).

And I like that. A lot. I hate communal stretching--I like to do stretching my own way, and I don't like paying for someone else to show me how to stretch--and I don't like communal workouts to count as part of training time. I can handle that on my own. I'm there for teaching and practice, and that's all we did.

It was a slow night, just one other student, and so I had the good fortune of some extra attention, while not getting to perhaps get a feel for a 'normal' class, in some respects. His other student, a blue belt, was skilled, and courteous. I went with her first; after surprising her with an early submission, we had a longer roll that was still controlled and respectful, which speaks a lot to the tone of the gym. Then I rolled with Dave. Dave went slow with me at first, very gentle, and snuck a slow triangle in before I realized what was going on.

When it came time to roll with him a second time, he went much closer to full force, pushing it up to maybe 85%. That being said, one gets the impression that he never goes higher than 92% outside of competition, and even that only when he's having an unusually bad day. Some people are looking for a more aggressive environment; Dave offers a more methodical one.

This time the round lasted a lot longer. It's hard to gauge time when you're rolling, but it felt like at least 10 or 15 minutes. I was pinned with him on my back for a lot of that, a sort of stalemate. I pulled out a few times, only to be dragged in. Eventually, I caved in on exhaustion.

Fun. My neck was sore the next day from all the time on the ground, but fun.

Then the technique portion of the class began. The class of moves we learned related to pendulum throws, and were clever, novel, and interesting. Class was a little fast-paced, and we didn't get to practice both sides (which he acknowledged), but in exchange we got more breadth. Pretty engaging stuff, without going over our heads.

End of class, we rolled a bit more. You could tell the instructor was enjoying himself, not just doing his job.

We talked afterwards. Dave gave me an honest evaluation of where I was (which he was correct in judging me open towards receiving), and gave me straight talk about money that was still comfortable in its honesty.

I have to admit, the jiu jitsu was good--but beyond that, it's the character of the guy leaves me wanting to come back. I have a feeling I haven't seen the last of this place... But at the price, unfortunately, it might be a while.

Some other notes:
They jog together on Sundays in the evening, optional.
They only have classes on week nights (Mon, Tue, Thur), with one no-gi class Saturday at noon.
David has an online repository of techniques on his website free of charge, which is a pretty noble effort.

Pros:
Experienced, multi-background, instructor
Character
Clean facility
Small classes
Established
Respectful atmosphere
Good class structure
Quality instruction

Cons:
Smallish classroom
Payment plan is lump sums
Classes-to-cost is on the more expensive side no matter how you cut it
Parking can be tough if you're not on a motorcycle
Rented space means you can't linger forever rolling, it seems.

Sample video of his from bjjtech.com:

Genesis: The Menu

Hi.

This site is where I'm going to keep track of my attempt to skim the surface of the Brazilian Jiu Jitsu scene.

Let's backtrack a bit:

I'm a poorer than average joe wanting to get back into BJJ, and so in the interest of frugality, I decided to look around at the cost of BJJ in Austin, see if there wasn't some smaller gig than the dojo I learned at many years before that might be significantly cheaper.

Turns out there's more than 15 places you can practice Brazilian Jiu Jitsu in Austin--and only one of them lists their price online. I kept 13 on my list, and there may be more I don't know about. (Feel free to recommend some more!).

Now, I don't know about you, but I've always been the kind of guy who reads the menu twice over before making his selection. These gyms all insist that you can't rate the price-to-product ratio until you come in, and all are asking me to come in.

So you know what? I'm going to try them all. Then I'm going to write about it here and let you know what I found out, so you don't have to deal with this crap.

Most of these places give a free class (with the exception of Vandry?). Two of them give a free week. One gives two weeks free. Another gives a month half off if you go through Yelp.

Between all of these, I should learn not only a lot of Jiu Jitsu, but also a lot about the Austin BJJ scene,  Teaching styles, and Dojo styles. I will learn what I want when I eventually can afford the best. And I'll be able to give some good recommendations to friends.

Who am I?

I'm from Austin, and started Brazilian Jiu Jitsu in my teen years. Before that, I had done a smattering of some other martial arts, but nothing of note.

I became very passionate about BJJ, though, and pursued it fervently for a season--until I ran out of money. Later, I left the country for university, and continued even poorer than I had been before. I did do some martial arts for a short time with some incredibly quality folks that cross-trained in several martial arts (including BJJ), with an instructor who asked for only whatever I could afford. But aside from that, and the occasional friendly bout with a friend or family member, I was left only with longing.

None of these reviews are paid for. None of the dojos know they are being reviewed here, or written about. None of them have been warned.

Just some honest reviews and information. Hope it helps someone out there.

These are the places on my list, in no particular order:

Rubicon Fightsport
Martial Arts Center Austin
Paragon BJJ
John's Gym
Joao Crus BJJ
Austin Jiu Jitsu
Relson Jiu Jitsu
Claunch BJJ
Rabadi
Gracie Barra
Vasquez Academy  (Did not like talking to these guys on the phone, too far south anyways).
Cleber BJJ
South Austin Gym
Kokoro (co-op Judo)
Vandry*
Zen Jiu Jitsu
Team Haas Judo

*Vandry doesn't offer a free class, according to a Yelp review. We'll see if that's correct or not.